American Horror Story Season 3: Episode 5 – Burn, Witch. Burn!

AHs3In last week’s episode Delphine appeared to imply that she was unfamiliar with the idea of ‘trick or treat’ as part of Halloween. Not so – the opening scene shows she threw Halloween parties that focused on tricks rather than treats. Potential suitors for her daughters were asked to put their hands in covered bowls of real eyeballs and innards rather than the peeled grapes and sausages they may have been expecting. Delphine’s daughters see yet another potential suitor (the Governor’s son no less) being frightened off by their mother and so they begin to hatch a plot to get rid of her. Learning of this, she has her daughters imprisoned in the attic and threatens to keep them there for a year – saving the worst punishment for the ringleader Borquita.

In the modern day, as Halloween evening progresses, the witches at the school find themselves surrounded by zombies and it is the reanimated bodies of Delphine’s daughters, led by Borquita, who make it to the front door first.

A Zombie Attack

Just before the zombies arrived, Luke had delivered Halloween cookies much to Nan’s delight. Luke believes the zombies to be local kids playing a prank so he goes outside to try to reason with them. He is amongst them as Marie commands the zombies to ‘begin’ and they start to attack – eviscerating a group of local teens who had gone to marvel at their prosthetics. Zoe has to stop Delphine from going outside to find Borquita and misses Nan slipping outside to try to save Luke. Zoe takes charge inside the house and sends Queenie and Delphine upstairs out of harm’s way before going outside to try to save Nan. Luke has been injured and Nan gets him to relative safety inside a car. The zombies soon begin to break into the car but they are distracted by Zoe who draws them away and takes what is obviously temporary shelter in a garden shed. Nan tries to get the wounded Luke back to the house but the zombies soon have them surrounded.

As all seems lost, Zoe emerges from the shed with a chainsaw and hacks the zombies into pieces. One zombie remains as the chainsaw stops working and for a moment it looks like Zoe may be defeated. Suddenly she raises her hand, mutters an incantation and the zombie falls to the ground. Marie’s magic has been disrupted and whilst she’s not sure what happened Marie is sure that ‘they’ve got some real power in that witch house now’.

Meanwhile, Borquita has made her way to the kitchen window where Delphine sees her and is overcome with maternal guilt. She lets the zombie into the house and expresses her regrets for being a terrible mother and she offers to try to make amends. Borquita responds by attempting to choke Delphine.

Borquita then makes her way upstairs attacking Spalding and Queenie. Queenie tries to fight back but her magic cannot stop the zombie’s attack. Borquita is finally bought down by Delphine with a poker through the heart. Delphine realises that this releasing her from Marie’s spell been the only act of maternal kindness Delphine had ever offered her daughter.

Screen Shot 2013-11-23 at 08.44.52

An Acid Attack

Claudia has been badly disfigured by the acid attack at the bar and Fiona rushes her to hospital. The doctor says that Cordelia has been blinded by the attack. Fiona, unable to cope with the news, self-medicates and then goes to find the hospital pharmacy for more supplies. She manages to acquire a cocktail of pills to add to the alcohol she has with her and, in a foggy state, makes her way through the hospital.

Screen Shot 2013-11-23 at 08.49.33

She is clearly feeling guilty about what has happened to Cordelia: she hallucinates being told that she ‘might as well have’ thrown the acid in her daughter’s face.  She pauses as she wanders the hospital halls to bring life to a stillborn baby placing her back in the arms of her mother.

Fiona is at Claudia’s bedside when Hank returns and she vents her anger at him. She tells him he can have 15 minutes with her daughter but then she wants him to disappear – his way or (unspecified, but decidedly ominously) her way. Hank offers his love and support to Cordelia but when he takes her hand Cordelia has a vision and she is aware of his infidelity.

‘Fire purges and purifies’

The next morning Nan and Zoe are busy burning the zombie bodies and Fiona thanks Zoe for protecting the coven. Delphine expresses her maternal regret and she and Fiona appear to be sharing some common ground. Delphine hopes their shared tragedies may bring them closer together but Fiona dismisses the idea declaring that she doubts it as Delphine is ‘after all, the maid’.

The council arrives back at the school and this time they are intend to remove Fiona from the coven by demanding her abdication. Fiona turns the tables back on them and implicates Myrtle in the attack on Cordelia. When Fiona reveals acid burns on Myrtle’s hand and the fact that she was in New Orleans when Madison disappeared, the council declares Myrtle guilty and she is sentenced to death by fire. Myrtle says that she is innocent but goes ‘proudly to the flame’. She is clearly horrified but her love for the coven runs deep. She said she had always felt like an outsider but thought she belonged in the coven.


The execution takes place in a scene reminiscent of a 70s spaghetti western/Tarantino movie and is accompanied by Dr. John’s Right Place Wrong Time. Zoe can’t believe what the coven are about to do. Myrtle warns them that Fiona will bring danger to them all. Fiona lights the fire and Myrtle dies in agony before the collected witches.


Post Script 1

Queenie goes to Fiona as she realises she was involved in framing Myrtle. Queenie caused the burns on Myrtle’s hand by putting her own hand in acid and passing the wound on to the council member. Queenie’s guilt is soon soothed by Fiona’s promise to mentor her for the role of Supreme. Queenie likes the idea of being the first Supreme of ‘colour’ and seems to forget about Myrtle as she accepts Fiona’s offer of tutelage.

Post Script 2

Screen Shot 2013-11-23 at 08.58.30

Spalding, still dressed in nightgown and bonnet, has Madison’s redressed body in a basket. The smell is clearly awful and he tries to cover it with air freshener. Madison’s body is decomposing to the extent that when he tries to take her out of the basket, her arm comes clean away.

Post Script 3

Misty Day appears at the Myrtle’s execution site and finds the horribly burned body. She takes hold of Myrtle’s face and uses the power of resurgence to bring life back to the dead witch.

Screen Shot 2013-11-23 at 08.55.13

Themes and Issues

Maternal Instinct

Like episode 3, this episode is about motherhood but instead of a focus on bad mothering, this episode looks at the maternal instinct and how, even in the most selfish or cruel mothers, the desire to protect is undeniable. Both Delphine and Fiona have been terrible mothers. Delphine was active in her physical and psychological abuse of her daughters whilst Fiona was a bad mother though neglect and absence. Fiona has been absent for much of Cordelia’s life but when present she is hyper-critical and acts totally in her own self-interest. Cordelia’s own instinct to become a mother drew her in desperation to ask Marie for help when she discovers she cannot conceive. Unsurprisingly, Fiona berates her for this saying she is showing weakness. She also accuses Cordelia of being an inadequate mother-figure for the girls in the school. Fiona’s behaviour changes though when Cordelia is hurt and in acts of maternal protection she rushes her daughter to the hospital and demands that Hank leaves Cordelia alone. Having seen Hank’s true nature in the previous episode we cannot help but side with the ferocious mother who wants to protect her daughter from this ‘loser’. With Cordelia hurt, the instinct to protect motivates Fiona’s actions but the knowledge of how bad a mother she has been drives her into inebriated guilt. Her act in bringing the stillborn child to life acts as a channel for her to express how she feels about Cordelia. She gets the grieving mother to say things to her baby that presumably Fiona has never said to Cordelia. Despite the fact that Fiona has been critical and judgmental each time we have seen her interact with her daughter, this is the ‘second chance’ she wishes she had. She gets the grieving mother to tell her daughter she will never leave her and that ‘she’ll be [her] mother’ forever.

Delphine too finds herself instinctively drawn to her daughters despite the fact that they are zombies and that they are threatening her and everyone in the coven. When alone with Borquita, she tries to reason with her daughter and acknowledges what a terrible mother she has been. When Borquita attacks Delphine, the mother is passive but when Borquita threatens Queenie, she fights back. Since Queenie has saved her life, Delphine has taken on the role of mother to the young witch; nurturing and protecting her. Delphine’s relationship with Queenie may now be under threat as Fiona has stepped in to act as Queenie’s tutor and mentor.

Other mothers in the episode include Zoe, who takes charge and acts ferociously to protect the coven and Myrtle who declares she was more of a mother to Claudia than Fiona has been. Spalding perverts the idea of motherhood by dressing up and arranging a tea-party. His children are dolls or the poor dead Madison.



  • Cross cultural references abound: from The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Shining (twice) to every Zombie movie/TV show ever made but especially Night of the Living Dead.


  • Fiona’s spaced out meanderings around the hospital were one part Silent Hill, one part The Cabinet of Dr Caligari and another part American Horror Story: Asylum.


  • Zoe embodies every ‘final girl’ (Clover) who is left battling monsters in the horror genre and there was a little Buffy the Vampire Slayer in there too.


  • Did Kathy Bates channel her character Annie Wilkes in Misery in her line ‘break a leg if you must’? This is the second character Bates has played for whom hobbling is a solution.

Line of the Week

  • Fiona (to Hank): I can smell the bullshit in your pockets


Austerity Politics – it just won’t go away

It’s clear that the politics of austerity and the multitude of austerity related issues is the dominant political context right now. Further developments over the past couple of weeks have involved an old Tory Prime Minister, the current Tory Prime Minister, a waitress, some students and some activists in V for Vendetta/Guy Fawkes masks. The work of Naomi Klein and her book/film on disaster capitalismThe Shock Doctrine, seems increasingly relevant.

First of all, students in Manchester (and since then, students from many other universities) have complained that the academic discipline of Economics is stuck in its pre-crash mind-set. Rather than update economic thinking they argue that the academics do nothing but repeat ideas that have been proved to be false and they do not encourage debate, discussion or free-thinking. It’s almost as if these academics were in the pay of banking institutions or neo-liberal lobby groups! One of the theories not taught on some economics degree courses apparently, is Marxist economic theory.

Another group of agitators, Occupy, have bought $15m of US personal debt (largely healthcare debt) for $400,000 and have written it off. People have been freed from crippling debt bills for a fraction of the cost to the individuals themselves. Read the story and the analysis here.


Another revolutionary (almost) act came from a less expected source. The former Conservative Prime Minister, John Major, said he was shocked at the stalling of social mobility in the UK and the fact that the political class was dominated by an affluent public school educated elite. David Cameron agreed – although he seems to think it’s because the lower-orders have low aspirations rather than any other social-economic reason.

He also apparently saw no conflict between these comments on social mobility and those made several days earlier during this speech (be sure to watch the video) at a banquet held in London. A waitress at the Lord Mayor’s banquet had this to say.


This acknowledgement that austerity is not just an attempt to deal with post-crash economic problems but an ideological position - quite different to what was claimed as the Coalition was formed in 2010. If you want to check out what Cameron and other Conservative politicians had to say before May 2010, that’s just become a lot harder though as the party have deleted the archived speeches from their website.

According to The Guardian,

‘ the party has also blocked access to the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine, a US-based library that captures webpages for future generations, using a software robot that directs search engines not to access the pages.’

This purge has also included the removal of YouTube videos. Make of that what you will.


Finally – here’s something on lobbying you might be interested to know.


American Horror Story Season 3: Episode 4 – Fearful Pranks Ensue

As this is the first of a two part episode, the themes and issues will be considered next week.

What happened this week?

The opening of the episode takes us back to 1961, and a culture taking its first steps towards racial integration. Cora, an employee of Marie’s in the salon has sent her son to a racially integrated high-school. She is filled with optimism despite all the other women’s words of caution.  Tragically Cora’s son is found lynched and, in retaliation, Marie summons zombies to exact revenge. Whilst in a trance, Marie is able to raise the dead and control them and she sends them to mutilate the white men who killed Cora’s son. Later we learn that after years of bloodshed in the conflict between the two tribes, Marie became the hero of a truce called between the white witches and Voodoo culture. Further conflict was avoided by drawing firm boundaries between the communities and ensuring neither crossed over into the other group’s territories.

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 10.57.17

Marie and Anna-Leigh call a truce to the conflict between the witches and voodoo culture.

At the School

This episode offers a little insight into Spalding’s strange world as we see him taking tea with his large collection of dolls. This takes place just before the events of episode 3 and we see Fiona killing Madison again, but this time from Spalding’s point of view. The silent butler is willing to remove the body and look after Fiona.

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 10.53.38

Spalding holds a dolly tea party

As Spalding prepares to move Madison, Fiona hears a noise in the greenhouse and finds Queenie beaten and bloodied after her encounter with the Minotaur. Fiona wakes Cordelia who tries to heal some of Quennie’s wounds with a poultice but Queenie’s injuries are severe and Cordelia’s magic fails. Queenie dies but Fiona breaths life back into her. She is, however, furious with Cordelia for going to Marie for help and, in her eyes, undermining the coven. She also berates Cordelia for losing control over the girls in the school, allowing them to get themselves into dangerous situations.

A Visit from the Council of Witchcraft

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 11.01.29

The council arrives

As Queenie begins to recover, Nan announces that the school is being visited by the Council of Witchcraft in the form of Pimbrooke, Quentin and Fiona’s old adversary, Myrtle Snow. In her panic, Claudia tells the council about the attack on Queenie and then her visit to Marie in the belief that these events are what drew the council members to the school. They reveal they are there as Nan suspects that Madison is dead. The Council begins to question the witches and after Nan tells them that Madison’s magic powers were developing. Myrtle is convinced that she now knows what has happened and she lists Fiona’s ‘failings’ as the Supreme and connects Fiona to the deaths of both Anna-Lee and Madison. The punishment for harming another witch is death by fire.

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 11.08.01

The council mounts an investigation

A flashback takes us back to the school in 1971 when Fiona is announced as Supreme and Myrtle already has her suspicions feeling sure that Fiona is lying about what happened to Anna-Lee. Myrtle notices Spalding’s unquestioning loyalty to Fiona and she casts a spell that would make it impossible for Spalding to utter a lie. Later than night Spalding is found with his tongue cut out. Spalding, knowing he would be forced to speak against Fiona, summons her and tells her he loves her. He then proceeds to cut out his own tongue with a razor. Myrtle clearly believes Fiona to be responsible for the mutilation and in the present day Spalding is told to write down the name of the witch responsible for his injuries – he writes ‘Myrtle Snow’. Myrtle is enraged as Fiona keeps ‘getting away with it’. Cordelia tells Myrtle that her logic is wrong as Madison could not be the next Supreme as she did not have the ‘glowing radiant health’ that characterises a Supreme in waiting. Fiona is shocked to learn she has killed the wrong girl.


Kyle, still bloody from the murder of his mother, is disintegrating further. Zoe finds him beating his head against the side of the bath and the distraught Zoe realises that re-animating him has been cruel and has done nothing but caused huge mental torment for the boy. She decides to make his some food and whilst preparing it she sees a packet of rat poison. We see her reaching for the packets and then she takes the food to Kyle. By the time she gets back to the bathroom, Kyle has gone.


Claudia believes her husband to be in Baton Rouge for work but he is there to meet with a woman (Kaylee) and they are soon in bed together.

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 10.59.28

Kaylee doesn’t know what’s in store for her

Hank is almost demonically enthusiastic in bed and the couple soon seem to be relaxed and comfortable with each other in the domestic setting they are creating for themselves. Kaylee expresses how much she likes Hank and, without warning he takes a gun from his waistband and shoots her in the head.

Halloween Begins

Cordelia and Fiona began the episode at odds with one another and Fiona is livid that Cordelia may have undermined Fiona in the eyes of the Voodoo Queen. Later Fiona steps in to take over from Cordelia when she is talking to the council, again showing her disappointment in the way her daughter is handling the situation. After Fiona learns that Madison could not have been the next Supreme she takes Cordelia out for drinks where they promise to be truthful with one another. Fiona of course lies without pause when asked if she killed Madison. Cordelia avoids Fiona’s question about who the next Supreme may be and having drunk too much is later attacked in the bathroom by a masked and hooded character who throws what appears to be acid in her face.

As Halloween begins Nan mourns the passing of Madison but Zoe says they cannot be sure she is dead. Meanwhile, Spalding continues his Halloween tea-party, this time dressing some of the dolls in costumes and dressing himself in a nightdress and bonnet. We see that he has a guest of honour as he has not disposed of Madison’s body after all – she is propped up in a chair with a cup and saucer amongst the other dolls.

As a post script to the opening scene Marie is doing the now elderly Cora’s hair in preparation for the Mayor’s Halloween banquet. After the attack on Queenie, Bastien has been decapitated and his head sent back to the Voodoo Queen. It appears that, despite losing his head, the immortality spell has kept him alive and Marie is outraged at what has been done to him. She breaks the truce between the witches and the voodoo community by raising zombies in retaliation for Bastien’s decapitation. The zombies, including Delphine’s daughters, have been sent to attack the school.

Quote of the week – runner up 1

  • Fiona: Who’s the baddest witch in town?

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 10.56.40

This is the baddest witch in town

Quote of the week – runner up 2

  • Myrtle (to Fiona): You must think you’re very clever.
  • Fiona: I do. I do think I’m very clever.

Quote of the Week

  • Fiona: Why Myrtle Snow. Look at you! Developing a sense of style when no one was paying attention.

Biggest hint of a plot twist in dialogue of the week

  • Kaylee: I think Halloween gives people the permission to be who they really want to be. Do you dress up? Who were you last year?
  • Hank: Me? I was a monster.

Coincidence of the Week

Even though it seems unlikely to be connected, the name of the man Hank has told Cordelia he is in Baton Rouge to meet is Phil Underwood – a name shared by a UK based folk musician specialising in Cajun and Zydeco music!


American Horror Story Season 3: Episode 3 – The Replacements

In episode one the term abject is used a couple of times. The use of the word and its meaning is discussed by Anne Peterson here: if things were abject in earlier episodes, then episode 3 makes us face the gross and the debased head-on.


What happened this week?

The episode begins with Fiona having a restless night, seemingly haunted by the memory of her ascension to the role of Supreme back in 1971. She murdered Anna-Leigh, the existing incumbent, by slashing her throat and this was witnessed by Spalding the butler. Fiona’s power has been seen before – but this is the first time we have witnessed her murderous side. Her younger self is shown taking power from the old and ill Supreme but in the modern day, she is having to deal with the fact that her power is reducing as she gets older. In her quest for youthfulness she visits a plastic surgeon and we see her grief at the waning of the power of youth as he shows her the procedure for a facelift. Fiona is having to deal with the fact that she is no longer young and desirable but as she has grown older she has become invisible to men and will soon need to make way for a younger women who will take her role and position in the coven from her.

Both Fiona and Cordelia are shown visiting doctors and getting bad news. Fiona’s doctor will not do the plastic surgery she wants as she is seriously ill (we later learn she has cancer) and Cordelia is told she cannot have a baby. In desperation, Cordelia visits Marie to ask her to perform voodoo magic to help her conceive but Marie refuses as Cordelia was ‘born into the wrong tribe’. Cordelia is distraught to learn that Fiona has indirectly ensured she will not be able to have a baby as Marie won’t even entertain the idea of helping Cordelia simply because she is Fiona’s daughter.

Delphine and Queenie

Fiona decides that Delphine has to make herself useful by being taking on the role of maid within the school. Her first job is to serve lunch to the girls but Delphine cannot deal with the idea of serving Queenie and she throws the girl’s food against the wall. Much to Queenie’s delight, Fiona punishes Delphine by making her Queenie’s ‘personal slave’. Queenie uses this power to get Delphine to prepare food for her and, when criticised about her weight, she quotes Dr Phil and puts down her love of food down to a lack of love as a child. Whilst in the kitchen, they hear a noise outside and Delphine looks to see Bastien (in the form of a Minotaur) attempting to break into the house. Delphine tells Queenie who she really is and that the Minotaur is after her. Queenie goes outside to find Bastien. She talks to him and likens the way people treat her to the way he was treated. She offers herself to him sexually and he responds to her advances. At first he is quite gentle but he clamps his hand across her mouth and as we leave the scene we hear Queenie scream.

Zoe and Kyle


Zoe visits Kyle’s mother (Alicia) who is bereft at the loss of her son. She tells Zoe that she was considering suicide – and only changed her mind when Zoe called to offer her condolences. Alicia’s wish is to see Kyle one last time ‘if only to say goodbye’. Zoe tells Alicia that ‘Kyle has not left us’ and goes to find Kyle who has been living with Misty. Kyle is still largely unresponsive – even when Misty partially undresses him to show Zoe how well he has healed. He does not react when Misty attempts to get close to him but he treats Zoe with some tenderness.  Zoe wants to take Kyle back to his mother but Misty wants to keep him and Zoe with her. She has cared for Kyle and it is clear she feels rejected and abandoned – especially when Kyle actively chooses to go with Zoe.

Zoe takes Kyle back home and Alicia is shocked at first but she accepts him back. She does, however, notice that his body is different. Madison had chosen a range of boy parts from the victims of the bus crash and he is an amalgam of various boys’ body parts. Once home though, it is clear that Alicia’s relationship with Kyle is not a healthy one. She molests her son and, although Kyle is still non-responsive, it is clear he is horrified by the physical relationship she forces on him. Alicia is clearly worried by the difference she sees in Kyle and she calls Zoe. Before Zoe can get to Kyle’s home, Alicia seduces him again and he finally rejects his mother. In his rage he picks up a sports trophy and beats his mother to death. Zoe arrives to find Alicia dead on the bedroom floor and Kyle covered in his mother’s blood.

Madison and Fiona

Queenie and Nan are joined by Madison in an appreciation of the finely chiseled form of a young new neighbour (Luke) moving into the house next door. They later decide to take a welcome cake – Nan wants to be neighbourly whereas Madison wants to get laid. Despite Madison’s best efforts Luke is more interested in Nan and the cake than in her. She is both shocked and angered by this and when she learns that Luke is from a Christian background she attacks their religion and in a struggle she throws the cake knife into the wall and sets the curtains on fire as she leaves. Both Nan and Madison are surprised by this new power.

Fiona learns that Madison’s powers appear to be growing when Luke’s mother visits to complain about the girls’ behaviour. Fiona takes a sudden interest in Madison when it’s confirmed she can control fire. She takes Madison out to find out what powers Madison has. Fiona describes herself as a ‘horrible mother’ and Madison offers her a second chance to take on a maternal role by passing her knowledge on. Fiona takes Madison to one of her old haunts – a bar she used to visit when younger. They drink and play pool together. Fiona has all her fears confirmed as she sits on the sidelines watching the younger woman enjoying being the centre of attention. They return home and Fiona shows Madison the portraits of the previous Supremes and Fiona tells her she will be the next one. She tells Madison that the young woman’s ascension is killing Fiona as power is being transferred from her to Madison and her body is failing – ready to make way for her replacement. Fiona has many regrets about her life. She admits to Madison that she murdered her predecessor and demands that Madison does the same. She gives a knife to Madison and orders her to cut her throat. Madison refuses and in the struggle, Fiona kills Madison. Whilst the argument seemed spontaneous, Fiona’s response implies this may not have been an accident. Spalding has witnessed everything and Fiona tells him to bury Madison. He provides a handkerchief for Fiona to wipe the blood from her hands.

Media Language

Much of the strangeness of the show is in the visual direction. Some very unusual techniques are used which act to show familiar scenes and objects in unfamiliar ways. This adds to the disconcerting effect of the content of the show itself. Here are some examples:

Dutch (Oblique) Angle

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.42.11

Fish Eye Lens

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.23.36


Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.24.07

Sideways shot

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.23.11

Crane Shot

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 09.20.28

Music too is used to reinforce the uneasy tone. Often the music is selected to work with the scene; for example, at the frat party in episode 2 or this episode’s voodoo ceremony. Other musical choices are used as themes and are repeated throughout the programme. Two standout uses of music are:

  • The LaLa LaLa Song by James Levine. This is a recurrent theme and is played throughout the episode – especially at scene changes and often over images of ‘normal’ events (even if presented in distinctly abnormal way). The music plays as we begin the breakfast scene with Fiona and Madison as we see the yellow bus passing the by the cafe (above).
  • Songs by Stevie Nicks – especially Rhiannon and Sara – accompany visits to the bayou and Misty’s cabin. The ethereal sound of Stevie Nick’s vocal has been highlighted by Misty’s obsession with the singer and the belief that Stevie too is a witch. This unusual context means we hear the songs in a new way and the familiar becomes unfamiliar.

Themes and Issues


It should be no surprise that the most disturbing thing for Delphine as she is adjusting to the modern world is the fact that Obama is president and she is horrified by the fact that a black man is the leader of the US. Despite the witchcraft and murder, it appears Fiona sympathises with liberal politics. We learn that she’s a Democrat (’I voted for him – twice’) and there is nothing she hates more than racists.

Queenie and Delphine have been forced together and Queenie’s heritage as being a descendant of Tutuba make this both an unlikely pairing and one that may lead to more friction between them. Delphine’s racism is deeply ingrained and Queenie responds aggressively to each racial slur or attack. With Queenie’s seduction of the Minotaur it is likely that she will find herself in conflict with Marie – so Queenie and Delphine could find themselves united by a common enemy.


There are several examples of motherhood within this episode – it is difficult to find a particularly positive representation of a mother here though:

  • Joan – tries to protect her son Luke from the sexual advances of young women. Her puritanism makes her overbearing and irrational.
  • Alicia – her love for her son has been perverted and she is sexually abusive.
  • Zoe and Madison – both acted as parents to ‘Franken-Kyle’ but Madison left Zoe to deal with the maternal responsibilities.
  • Misty – has acted as a healer and a nurturer when she offered to take Kyle in. However, her relationship with Kyle seemed uncomfortably close as they shared a bed and, mirroring Kyle’s relationship with his own mother, she seems more keen to be close than he does. Kyle’s rejection of Misty clearly hurts her enormously.
  • Cordelia – is desperate to become a mother but she is unable to conceive. Neither medical science nor her own magic can help her but she finds her own mother’s desire for immortality has taken away the chance to seek help with voodoo magic.
  • Fiona – has failed as a mother with her own daughter Cordelia but seems keen to offer maternal support to Madison when she is to be the next Supreme. The death of this surrogate-daughter mirrors Fiona’s murder of Anna-Leigh. Fiona’s desire for power has caused her to pervert the mother/daughter relationship by committing both matricide and infanticide.


Although the show is dominated by female characters, the conventional notion that women are used as narrative devices for the male characters is challenged. Madison is a character who sees herself as a sexual object and she represents the narcissism that might be associated with a Hollywood child star. Unusually though, she is not often objectified and the show is making interesting use of the sexualised gaze. She dresses provocatively when she and Nan go to visit Luke as she wants to direct the gaze towards her sexual availability. Luke isn’t interested and he resists her. Madison is shocked that she has not been validated by the gaze – something she is used to. As Luke himself points out, she is used to being the centre of attention.

Usually it is women who are perceived as nothing more than body parts but, in episode 2, Madison viewed the victims of the bus crash in precisely this way. ‘Franken-Kyle’ is a hotchpotched concoction of the body parts chosen by her as she attempts to create the perfect ‘boyfriend’. Kyle is objectified by everyone other than Zoe. Misty treats Kyle as property and her displaying of his scars to Zoe reinforces his lack of power as does his passive acceptance of his mother’s advances. The incestuous relationship is a distortion of maternal love and Alicia’s adoration of her son has become physical and reinforces his powerlessness until Kyle fights back against the possessiveness of the relationship. Women are not being looked at via the male gaze (Mulvey) – all the sexualised gazes are so far focused on men.

Keeping Up-to-Date

Voodoo queens have traditionally read the future with tarot cards. This is Domino from the Bond film Live and Let Die reading the tarot cards.


Here, Marie shows she has moved with the times…

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.27.41

… by playing solitaire on her iPad.

Screen Shot 2013-11-10 at 10.28.44

Quote of the week

Discussing the fact that the US has a black president…

Fiona: We’ve also had black secretaries of state, Supreme Court justices and even the poet-laureate.

  • Delphine: Liiiiieeeess


American Horror Story Season 3: Episode 2 – Boy Parts



What happened this week?

Fiona, Mme. L and Marie

Fiona has Mme L locked up in the school and she discovers that, back in 1840, she was given an immortality potion by the voodoo queen Marie Laveau. Taking revenge for the inhuman treatment of her lover Bastien (who was turned into a Minotour), Marie murdered Mme L’s husband and daughters but the punishment for the now immortal Mme L was to be buried alive.

Fiona goes to the Ninth Ward where she finds the still beautiful and glamorous Marie Laveau running a hairdressing salon. In a tense discussion we learn that the practitioners of voodoo and witches have become enemies despite the fact that it was Tituba, a house slave and Voodoo Queen who taught the Salem witches the dark arts. Marie refuses to give Fiona what she wants – the immortality potion – and so Fiona starts a fire in the salon in an attempt to intimidate Marie and as a display of her power.

Meanwhile, the telepath Nan is annoyed by the sound of Mme. L’s thoughts so Nan unties her and lets her go. Queenie investigates what’s going on and Mme. L knocks her unconscious after calling her ‘slave’, much to Queenie’s outrage. Mme. L escapes from the school to be found later by Fiona sitting on the porch of her old house. Mme. L is clearly disturbed by the fact that her house has become a ‘museum of horrors’ and she still experiences grief over the loss of her murdered daughters (but not so much over the loss of her husband). Fiona offers no sympathy and she takes Mme L back to the school after warning her she would re-bury her if she tried to escape again.

Zoe and Madison

Zoe finds it difficult to accept the death of Kyle given that he was not involved in the attack on Madison. Madison has little sympathy for him and sees him as ‘guilty by association’. The police arrive at the school. Zoe’s visit to the hospital was caught on CCTV and the police have connected the deaths of the frat boy and Zoe’s first boyfriend. Fiona deals with the police by casting a spell to make them forget their suspicions but only after Zoe, in a fit of panic, has admitted everything to the police. Fiona is enraged by the girls’ stupidity and reminds them that they are the ones with power and declares that, ‘in the whole wide wicked world, the only thing you have to be afraid of is me’.

Madison takes Zoe to the morgue where Madison breaks in. She has a resurrection spell and plans to bring Kyle back as a ‘thank you’ to Zoe for killing the frat boy who instigated the gang rape. The victims of the bus crash are in body bags but their remains are horribly mangled and are, quite literally, in pieces. Madison wants to mix and match the body parts to try to create the ‘perfect’ boyfriend. The girls sew body parts together and cast the resurrection spell. At first it appears that the spell fails as Kyle remains lifeless. Zoe remains behind to say a final goodbye to Kyle and is neatly caught when a coroner returns to the morgue. Kyle finally reanimates and kills the coroner. Zoe takes the disoriented boy out of the morgue and, as they drive away, Kyle gets more and more agitated.

To Zoe’s surprise Misty Day appears in the back of the car. By casting the resurrection spell the girls had attracted Misty to the morgue. We had been shown at the start of the episode that she had survived being burned at the stake – no doubt down to her gift of resurgence. Misty was found wandering the swamplands by alligator poachers who she killed when they threatened her. Poetically, she reanimated the alligators killed by the poachers who then dragged the men into the swamp. Misty takes Zoe and Kyle to her cabin in the swamp and treats Kyle’s wounds. She promises to look after him and insists that Zoe promises to return. Zoe does so but there is a sense that the sight of the murderous and agitated Kyle has disturbed her deeply.


Snippets of Information

  • We learn that Cordelia is married but is unable to get pregnant. She and her husband decide to use magic to help her conceive.
  • Before she came to the school, Queenie’s was the manager of a fried chicken shop. In response to a customer’s insults and their attempt to con extra food from her, she plunges her arm into boiling fat and transfers the injury to the customer. It is also revealed that she is a descendent of Tituba, the house slave mentioned by Fiona and Marie who was accused of being a witch at the start of the Salem witch-trials.
  • Marie has kept Bastien alive as the Miinatour and she releases him from the chains that have bound him saying that they have ‘some business to attend to’.

Themes and Issues

Immortality and Reproduction

As the episode offers less exposition, themes are beginning to develop. The past and the present collide in Fiona, Marie and Mme L’s story arc. At the centre of their relationship is the idea of immortality. In the first episode Fiona denies it is cosmetic youth she wants but declares she desires ‘vitality’. She is railing against the inevitability of ageing and the losses this brings. Her discovery of Mme. L shows her that there is a way to get what she wants and in her discussion with Marie we get a sense of desperation in her appeal. Of course immortality was used as a punishment for Mme. L and her emergence in the world has heightened her grief and sadness. The first thing she learns is that the world has moved on around her and she has no place in the modern world as everything that was real to her has become a museum. Her life is now a story, a myth and she has become irrelevant. Marie used immortality as a punishment but in keeping Bastien alive has also used it for selfish reasons. The fact that the Minotour needs to be chained up does not bode well.

The younger witches are involved with immortality too. Misty has immortality as a gift and can bring the dead back to life. We didn’t know the character before she was burned but she is clearly slightly unhinged. Her offer to look after Kyle and her appeals to Zoe to return, come across as needy. She has been shunned by her community, is not a part of the coven and is living in total isolation. Her immortality has removed her from the world and it appears that Kyle would simply be unable to integrate into regular society – certainly at this point. Reproduction is closely connected to the idea of immortality – if not for ourselves, then for our genetic line. The resurrection of Kyle is unashamedly a ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ tale. Madison abandons the ‘baby’ before its birth, Zoe finds herself overwhelmed and Misty steps in to care for Kyle in a semi-maternal fashion. Like American Horror Story: Murder House, pregnancy and birth look to be an important part of Coven.



Another issue that is bubbling under the surface is race. Queenie says she didn’t know there was such a thing as black witches but the discussion about Tituba indicates that there has been a division between the magic of voodoo and that of witches and that this division is largely racial. Mme. L’s violence was racial as she tortured and murdered slaves. Although her behaviour broke the ‘black codes’ that legislated the way that slaves should be treated (offering some ‘protection’ but ultimately reinforcing the supremacy of whites) Mme. L’s attitudes reflected the fact that the dominant white culture saw black people as low status and as property. Racial hatred was approved of and reinforced by the state of the time. Mme. L argues that she was a woman of her time implying that her attitudes to race (at least) were nothing more than ‘normal’ in her culture and her ingrained racism is shown in her response to meeting Queenie for the first time. Fiona is now in conflict with Marie as the witch wants what the voodoo queen has – it is clear this antagonism between the tribes is a race issue.

Quote of the Week

  • Policeman: Are you in charge here?
  • Fiona: I’m in charge everywhere.


Marxism at the BBC

I’m always looking for examples to demonstrate theoretical ideas in action so I was interested to see that there was a discussion on Marxism on Daily Politics this week (BBC 1st Nov). It makes interesting viewing as, in the same way The Daily Mail managed to make Ed Miliband appear more appealing to the electorate in their attempt to smear his father, Andrew Neil’s blustering attempts to belittle Owen Jones and Zoe Williams only made their analysis look more reasoned and reasonable.

I now have a wonderful resource that discusses alienation and demonstrates the simplification and demonisation of a complex idea (Marxism), it shows how capitalist consensus has removed Mr Neil’s ability to listen to anything that does not support his world view and how the BBC’s mocking tone and adversarial interviewing style acts to reinforce this consensus through the construction of false consciousness. All this and according to this survey, people apparently think the BBC has a left-wing bias.

For those that don’t know, Andrew Neil was a long time editor of The Sunday Times, was on the board of Sky TV and has written for The Daily Mail and The Spectator.